Chapter 10 - The Defense Collapses-10
On the third day of the trial, Defense Attorney Richard Sterling called his key expert witness to the stand—Dr. Aris Thorne, a retired neuro-psychiatrist.
Dr. Thorne took the oath, adjusted his glasses, and offered a calm, professional smile to the jury.
“Dr. Thorne,” Attorney Sterling began, stepping up to the lectern. “In your professional opinion, based on your examination of Mrs. Evelyn Miller, was she fully aware of the physical dangers associated with Neodymium magnetic spheres at the time of the incident?”
“Based on my neurological assessment,” Dr. Thorne testified, “Mrs. Miller suffers from early-stage vascular dementia, complicated by severe stress-induced cognitive decline. It is entirely plausible that she viewed these magnetic spheres as harmless novelty items, similar to candy, and lacked the executive cognitive function to comprehend the severe internal trauma they could cause.”
A soft murmur ran through the gallery. Evelyn’s attorney looked at the jury, offering a subtle nod of satisfaction.
Prosecutor Helen Vance stood up calmly for cross-examination. She walked to the lectern, holding a thick binder of financial records.
“Dr. Thorne,” Prosecutor Vance began smoothly. “You testified that Mrs. Miller suffered from 'severe cognitive decline' during the month of September, correct?”
“Yes, that is my medical opinion,” Dr. Thorne replied firmly.
“Are you aware,” Prosecutor Vance asked, pulling a document from her binder, “that on September 14th—the exact same week she fed these magnets to her granddaughter—Mrs. Miller logged into an encrypted online offshore trading platform and executed sixteen complex currency options trades totaling $450,000?”
Dr. Thorne blinked, shifting in his seat. “I... I was not provided with those financial records.”
“Are you also aware,” Prosecutor Vance continued, her voice rising with sharp intensity, “that on September 18th, Mrs. Miller visited a corporate notary in Escondido, successfully forged her daughter-in-law’s signature on a complex twenty-page legal insurance contract, and systematically routed the monthly payments through a secondary shell account to avoid detection by her son’s accountants?”
Dr. Thorne cleared his throat, pulling at his collar. “Well... cognitive impairment can fluctuate—”
“Does a person suffering from severe executive dementia manage a multi-million-dollar offshore gambling ledger while executing meticulous legal forgery?” Prosecutor Vance demanded, stepping right up to the witness stand.
“Objection! Argumentative!” Attorney Sterling shouted from the defense table.
“Overruled,” Judge Sterling ruled sternly. “The witness will answer the question.”
Dr. Thorne looked down at his hands, his professional composure completely shattered. “No... a person with severe executive dementia would likely be unable to execute those complex financial transactions.”
“Thank you, Doctor,” Prosecutor Vance said coolly, turning her back on him. “No further questions.”
May you like
In the gallery, Marcus Vance leaned over to me and whispered, “The defense just died on the stand.”
I looked over at Evelyn. Her head was hanging low, her hands resting motionless on the defense table. She knew, as everyone in that courtroom knew, that the wall of lies she had constructed over thirty years had finally crumbled into dust.
