Chapter 6 - The Arrest at the Family Dinner
-2-
Word travels through an extended family with the speed of wildfire fueled by gasoline. Within three hours of the police officers leaving our house, my phone had accumulated forty-seven missed calls and ninety-two text messages. Patricia called twenty-four times in a row, her voicemails transitioning rapidly from furious commands to hysterical crying, and finally to venomous curses wishing me a lonely, miserable life.
David packed a duffel bag around noon and announced he was going to stay at his mother’s house until I "came to my senses." I didn't try to stop him. I watched him carry his bag to his sedan through the front window without saying a word. The silence that filled the house once he left wasn't lonely; it was the most peaceful sensation I had experienced in six years.
The formal arrest warrant for Cassidy Reynolds was signed by a municipal judge at 3:00 PM on Thursday. Two hours later, two unmarked police cruisers drove down the quiet suburban street where Cassidy lived in her beige townhouse, parking right in front of her driveway while her children were still inside playing video games.
According to Marcus—who called Arthur Vance in a blind panic demanding to know what kind of lunatic wife his business partner David had married—Cassidy was in the middle of preparing baked ziti for a family dinner when heavy knocking rattled her front door. When she opened it expecting a neighbor or a food delivery, Sergeant Miller and Officer Torres placed her in stainless steel handcuffs right on her front porch, reading her rights aloud while three neighbors watched from their manicured lawns.
The irony was delicious. Cassidy, who had spent four summers treating my home like her private resort while treating me like an unpaid maid, was now being perp-walked past her own rosebushes in silver bracelets because she couldn't fathom the concept of consequences.
By 7:00 PM, the emergency family summit was convened not at our house, but in Patricia’s cramped living room.
Arthur Vance had advised me not to attend, but I drove over anyway, parking my car across the street and watching the front windows from a distance. Through the gauzy curtains, I could see shadows moving rapidly. Patricia was pacing back and forth, wringing her hands. David sat slumped on the edge of a floral armchair, staring at his phone. Marcus—having driven home early from his contracting job three counties away—was standing by the mantelpiece, looking furious, though whether his anger was directed at Cassidy for getting arrested or at me for calling the police was still unclear.
My phone buzzed. It was an unknown number, but I knew who it was before I even slid the answer icon.
"Elena!" Patricia’s voice shrieked through the speaker, so loud I had to pull the phone three inches away from my ear. "Are you completely insane? Have you lost every ounce of human decency? They put her in a holding cell! She’s sitting behind glass in a municipal jail while you sit in your empty house laughing at us!"
"I'm not laughing, Patricia," I said calmly, watching the shadows through my windshield. "I'm just watching the law take its course."
"Drop the charges!" Marcus's deep, gravelly voice cut in over the line, booming with aggressive authority. "I don't know what kind of game you're playing, Elena, but if you don't call that lawyer of yours right now and sign whatever paper gets my wife out of that jail cell before dark, I’m coming over to Elm Street myself, and we're going to have a very different conversation about your property!"
"Are you threatening me, Marcus?" I asked, my voice dropping into a cool, steady register. "Because my phone is currently connected to a speaker recording app that automatically transmits every second of this call directly to Sergeant Miller’s desk at the precinct."
There was an abrupt, stunned silence on the other end of the line. The heavy breathing of three panicked adults was all that filled the silence for five full seconds.
"You're a monster," Patricia whispered, her voice trembling with genuine terror. "You're a cold, calculating monster."
May you like
"No, Patricia," I replied softly. "I'm just the owner of the house your daughter decided to vandalize. Tell Cassidy I hope she enjoys the hospitality of the county jail. It has four walls, a concrete floor, and absolutely no pool."
I hung up the phone, turned off my engine, and put the car in drive. As I drove back toward Elm Street, I looked up at the evening sky, feeling lighter than I had in years. The storm wasn't over yet, but for the first time in my life, I was standing firmly in the eye of it, completely untouched.
